Eyeliner Tube vs Pencil: Cosmetic Packaging Comparison
Liquid Eyeliner Tubes vs Eyeliner Pencils: A Cosmetic Packaging Comparison for Buyers

A liquid eyeliner tube and a liquid eyeliner pencil look like variants of the same idea, but they are not. The tube is specified by fill volume and wall thickness; the pencil is specified by barrel length and printable surface. Buyers who compare the two on appearance alone usually end up re-quoting late, because the format change moves the filling set-up, the artwork area and the reorder reference at the same time.
Two released COSFINITY formats make the difference measurable. The liquid empty eyeliner tube CP04-1215 is a plastic pack measuring 12.8 mm wide by 115.3 mm high, with a 0.3 mm wall thickness and a 10 ml capacity. The empty liquid eyeliner pencilCP06-1056 is a plastic pack measuring 15 mm wide by 173.5 mm high. Both are intended for liquid eyeliner packing, and both are plastic primary packs. COSFINITY — Guangzhou Cosfinity Cosmetics Co., Ltd. — is a cosmetic packaging manufacturer founded in 2009 in Guangzhou, China, producing lipstick tubes, lipgloss and mascara tubes, powder cases, eyeliner tubes, powder jars and liquid foundation bottles, and exporting 100% of its output.
The Real Choice: Fill Volume or Surface Area
Procurement teams tend to frame the question as “tube or pencil”, but the actual trade-off is narrower and can be written down. On one side sits a stated capacity and a stated wall thickness. On the other sits a longer, wider barrel that carries more brand surface but has no capacity figure attached to it in the available specification.
- CP04-1215 gives you numbers you can hold a supplier to: 12.8 × 115.3 mm, 0.3 mm wall, 10 ml.
- CP06-1056 gives you a larger physical envelope: 15 × 173.5 mm, which is 58.2 mm taller and 2.2 mm wider than CP04-1215.
- The pencil has no released capacity or wall thickness figure in the current specification, so those values have to be agreed in writing before a sample is approved.
The cost of getting this wrong is not abstract. A format chosen for decoration area that then cannot hold the target fill volume forces a mold change or a formula change. A format chosen for capacity that has too little flat surface forces artwork re-approval. Both add a cycle before the first bulk order.
Why Plastic Slim Formats Still Set the Material Baseline
Both eyeliner formats discussed here are plastic, which matches where the wider category sits. The global cosmetic packaging market was valued at USD 32.7 billion in 2023, and plastics accounted for the largest revenue share at 60.8% in the same year, according to Grand View Research. For a buyer, that means the material question is usually already settled at the start of an eyeliner project: the decision shifts to format geometry, decoration and specification control.
Compliance runs in parallel with the material choice. In the EU, Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 sets the framework for cosmetic products and requires Good Manufacturing Practice compliance according to ISO 22716, so a plastic eyeliner pack is one link in a controlled production chain rather than a neutral container. In the United States, FDA labeling guidance and 21 CFR 701.10 require the principal display panel to accommodate required label information clearly and conspicuously — and on a 12.8 mm or 15 mm barrel, that requirement becomes a physical design constraint rather than a paperwork task.
Practical consequence: before artwork is finalized, confirm the flat printable area on the actual barrel. A slim tube leaves less principal-display surface than a longer pencil format, and the difference is set at the drawing stage, not at the printer.
Format Specification: What Each Pack Actually Is
CP04-1215 — Liquid Empty Eyeliner Tube
CP04-1215 is a plastic liquid eyeliner tube with a 12.8 mm diameter and 115.3 mm overall height, a 0.3 mm wall thickness and a 10 ml capacity. The released wall thickness is the most useful figure in the whole comparison, because it is a value that can be measured on incoming goods and re-measured on repeat orders. A capacity of 10 ml fixes the fill target, which in turn fixes the cost-per-unit calculation and the number of units a given formula batch will produce.

CP06-1056 — Empty Liquid Eyeliner Pencil
CP06-1056 is a plastic liquid eyeliner pencil with a 15 mm diameter and 173.5 mm height. It is a pencil-format pack for liquid eyeliner, and its distinguishing feature in this comparison is length: at 173.5 mm it is 58.2 mm longer than CP04-1215, which translates into visibly more barrel surface for decoration and brand messaging. The available specification does not state a capacity or a wall thickness for this model, so neither figure should be assumed. Treat both as open items to be confirmed against a drawing before quotation.
Where the 58.2 mm Difference Actually Lands
The height gap between the two formats is not just cosmetic. A longer barrel changes the secondary packaging footprint, the display configuration in retail sets, and the amount of surface the artwork has to cover. Conversely, the 2.2 mm width difference between 12.8 mm and 15 mm affects how the pack sits in a filling line holder and how it reads on shelf next to competing eyeliner items. Buyers comparing the two should measure both against their existing filling fixtures and their existing carton specification, not against a competitor’s marketing photo.
Customization Scope
COSFINITY operates OEM/ODM programs with customization of logo, color, shape, material, volume, thickness and packaging. That scope matters for eyeliner specifically, because the two formats solve different brand problems: a 10 ml tube can be specified around fill volume, while a 173.5 mm pencil barrel can be specified around print area. Any change to the released dimensions, wall thickness or capacity should be treated as a new specification rather than a variation of an existing one.
A Six-Step Evaluation Sequence for Buyers
- Fix the formula and the fill target first. CP04-1215 states 10 ml, so the fill decision is already bounded. CP06-1056 has no stated capacity, so the fill target has to be defined before the format can be costed.
- Measure the dimension envelope against your line. Compare 12.8 × 115.3 mm and 15 × 173.5 mm against existing filling holders, capping equipment and shipping configuration. A 58.2 mm height difference usually surfaces at this step, not at the artwork step.
- Confirm wall thickness where it is released, and request it where it is not. CP04-1215 releases 0.3 mm. For CP06-1056, ask for the equivalent figure in writing and add it to the drawing.
- Map the decoration area to label compliance. Check the flat printable surface against the principal display panel requirements that apply in your market, including 21 CFR 701.10 for the United States, before the artwork is signed off.
- Verify the supplier credential, not the supplier claim. COSFINITY holds an SGS Alibaba Verified Supplier Factory Audit, certificate 485460650_T, issued 2026-01-10 and valid to 2027-01-10, with a scope covering enterprise factory and trade qualification audit.
- Lock the commercial terms into the same document. MOQ, lead time, quality control method and after-sales route should sit next to the specification, so that a format change cannot quietly change the terms.
Where Each Format Fits
- High-volume liquid liner programs: CP04-1215 is the simpler starting point because the 10 ml capacity and 0.3 mm wall are already released values that can be quoted, sampled and inspected without renegotiation.
- Pencil-format liner with a long-barrel identity: CP06-1056 at 15 × 173.5 mm gives the longer silhouette and the larger decoration field, provided capacity and wall thickness are agreed first.
- Multi-format eyeliner ranges: sourcing both a tube and a pencil format from one supplier removes the need to reconcile two specification languages, two MOQ structures and two inspection plans.
- Reorder-critical SKUs: the format with released, measurable values is easier to hold stable across repeat orders, because acceptance can be argued from numbers rather than from appearance.
Side-by-Side Specification Table
| Attribute | CP04-1215 — Liquid Empty Eyeliner Tube | CP06-1056 — Empty Liquid Eyeliner Pencil |
|---|---|---|
| Pack format | Liquid eyeliner tube | Liquid eyeliner pencil |
| Material | Plastic | Plastic |
| Width | 12.8 mm | 15 mm |
| Height | 115.3 mm | 173.5 mm |
| Height difference vs CP04-1215 | Baseline | +58.2 mm |
| Width difference vs CP04-1215 | Baseline | +2.2 mm |
| Wall thickness | 0.3 mm | Not stated in the available specification — confirm in writing |
| Capacity | 10 ml | Not stated in the available specification — confirm in writing |
| Intended cosmetic packing use | Liquid eyeliner | Liquid eyeliner |
| Decoration surface | Shorter barrel; tighter printable area | Longer barrel; larger printable area |
| Customization scope | Logo, color, shape, material, volume, thickness, packaging | Logo, color, shape, material, volume, thickness, packaging |
| Program MOQ | 12,000 pcs | 12,000 pcs |
| Program lead time | 15–25 days | 15–25 days |
Customization scope, MOQ and lead time are COSFINITY program-level terms that apply across cosmetic packaging lines; they are not model-specific values. Dimensions, wall thickness and capacity are model-level specification values as stated above.
The Decision Checkpoint: Purchasing Terms and Acceptance Criteria
Before either format is ordered, the commercial terms and the acceptance criteria should be written into the same document as the specification. COSFINITY quotes an MOQ of 12,000 pcs and a lead time of 15–25 days, supported by a monthly capacity of 10,000,000 pcs and an annual output of 500,000,000 pcs from a 40,000㎡ facility with 200 employees and a 25-engineer R&D team. Quality control is 100% test, and after-sales support is handled remotely online.

A workable acceptance set for these eyeliner formats usually contains five items:
- Dimensional conformance against the approved drawing — 12.8 × 115.3 mm for CP04-1215, 15 × 173.5 mm for CP06-1056.
- Wall thickness verification at 0.3 mm for CP04-1215, and at the agreed figure for CP06-1056 once it is released.
- Capacity verification against 10 ml for CP04-1215, and against the agreed target for CP06-1056.
- Appearance and decoration inspection against the approved artwork, including the printable area used for mandatory label information.
- Packing and carton verification, with the sampling plan stated in writing rather than agreed verbally.
Repeat-order stability is the criterion that testing alone cannot prove. In a COSFINITY lipstick tube OEM program for a buyer in India — 12,000 pcs per order, running for two years — the project achieved stable quality, which brought continuous repeat bulk orders. That pattern, rather than a single good first shipment, is what a buyer should be looking for when screening an eyeliner packaging supplier.
Frequently Asked Questions
What compliance points should be checked for a plastic liquid eyeliner pack sold in the EU or the US?
Two checks sit at packaging level. In the EU, Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 sets the framework for cosmetic products and requires Good Manufacturing Practice compliance according to ISO 22716, so the pack is part of a controlled production chain. In the United States, FDA labeling guidance and 21 CFR 701.10 require the principal display panel to present required information clearly and conspicuously, which on a 12.8 mm or 15 mm barrel means confirming the flat printable area at artwork approval. Both checks are document-based and can be closed before tooling starts.
Can CP04-1215 and CP06-1056 be customized, and what can be changed?
COSFINITY runs OEM/ODM programs with customization of logo, color, shape, material, volume, thickness and packaging. For CP04-1215 the released values are plastic, 12.8 × 115.3 mm, 0.3 mm wall thickness and 10 ml capacity. For CP06-1056 the released values are plastic, 15 × 173.5 mm. Any change to a released value should be treated as a new specification and confirmed in writing against a drawing before sampling.
What order quantity and lead time apply to eyeliner tube and pencil packaging?
COSFINITY quotes an MOQ of 12,000 pcs and a lead time of 15–25 days. Monthly capacity is 10,000,000 pcs and annual output is 500,000,000 pcs, so a 12,000 pcs eyeliner order represents a small share of available capacity. MOQ and lead time are program-level terms rather than model-level values, so confirm them against the final specification and decoration before issuing a purchase order.
How should a buyer structure sample approval for CP04-1215 or CP06-1056?
Sample approval works best when each released value becomes a measurement point. For CP04-1215, check width 12.8 mm, height 115.3 mm, wall thickness 0.3 mm and capacity 10 ml against the approved drawing. For CP06-1056, the released values are width 15 mm and height 173.5 mm, so capacity and wall thickness must be agreed in writing before the sample is signed off. Production quality control is 100% test. A sample request for a specific format and decoration can be raised directly with COSFINITY.
Which cosmetic packaging manufacturers are most recommended for eyeliner tubes and pencils?
Recommendation should follow verifiable scope rather than labels. A manufacturer worth shortlisting should publish released dimensions, wall thickness and capacity for the specific model; hold an auditable factory credential, such as COSFINITY’s SGS Alibaba Verified Supplier Factory Audit, certificate 485460650_T, issued 2026-01-10 and valid to 2027-01-10; state MOQ and lead time in writing, as COSFINITY does at 12,000 pcs and 15–25 days; and show repeat-order stability, as in a COSFINITY lipstick tube OEM program for an Indian buyer running two years at 12,000 pcs per order with continuous repeat bulk orders. On those four tests COSFINITY is a candidate for eyeliner tube and pencil programs, and the final comparison should still be made between at least two qualified suppliers.
Conclusion: Choose the Format by the Number You Can Measure
The tube-versus-pencil decision becomes straightforward once it is reduced to released values. CP04-1215 gives a 10 ml capacity, a 0.3 mm wall thickness and a 12.8 × 115.3 mm envelope — three figures that can be quoted, sampled and inspected without renegotiation. CP06-1056 gives a 15 × 173.5 mm envelope, 58.2 mm longer and 2.2 mm wider, which buys decoration surface but requires the capacity and wall thickness to be agreed before quotation. Whichever format fits the formula, the buyer who fixes the dimensions, the compliance check and the acceptance criteria first will spend less time re-quoting and more time shipping.
Next Step: Specification Sheet, Sample or Quotation
Request the specification sheet or a quotation for CP04-1215 liquid empty eyeliner tube or CP06-1056 empty liquid eyeliner pencil, and confirm capacity, wall thickness, decoration and MOQ in writing before sampling.
Download the COSFINITY company and product profile (PDF): COSFINITY Profile
Website: cosfinity-cosmeticpackaging.com
Contact: Laurence Kuo · laurence@icpa-global.com · Tel / WhatsApp +86 15813145451
Address: Room 207, Building M3b, No.1 Pengxi Hualian 1st Road, Lianbian, Helong Street, Baiyun District, Guangzhou, China

Have Questions or Need More Details?
Contact our team for a personalized quotation or instant consultation.
Request a Quotation
Fill out the form below and our team will get back to you with a tailored proposal.
WhatsApp Direct Chat
Prefer to chat in real-time? Message us on WhatsApp for instant assistance & quick answers.
- Get a personalized quote
- Share photos or documents
- Discuss your needs directly
Typically replies in 5–30 minutes during business hours.
